In the second issue of Eye Lie Popeye, the Sea Hag and Judy return to Popeye's destroyed dock in disguise. Meanwhile, Popeye and his new crew salvage their business and reunite with old friends Whaler Joe and his wife. Eugene the Jeep arrives with a warning about 4th dimensional Time Hunters and the stakes are so much higher than anyone could have predicted. As the story of Eye Lie Popeye unfolds, the Sailor Man and his allies are drawn deeper into the mystery, hidden motives, and deeper layers to this sea-faring adventure.